3 users logged onTips: BlueJerseyDotCom (AIM) |      
Log In
Sign Up | Forgot Password?

NJ Democratic State Committee repeats insensitivity to the LGBTI community

by: Steven Goldstein, Garden State Equality chair

Sun Sep 10, 2006 at 01:12:42 AM EDT



(This is absolutely shameful. The DSC leadership has some serious explaining to do. - promoted by jmelli)

but all of you in the progressive community are our heroes, and we thank you with all our hearts.  I'm talking about what happened this weekend at the State Democratic Convention.  Hi, everyone, from Steven Goldstein.  Allow me to fill you in, with apologies to those of you who attended the convention already know.

Each Friday at the convention, different constituencies have different Caucus meetings.  This year, three organizations, Garden State Equality, New Jersey Stonewell Democrats and the Gender Rights Advocacy Association of New Jersey, produced the LGBTI Caucus.  We decided to do something different -- to present an entertainer at the end of our Caucus meeting.  We had an open bar and hired a Cher impersonator.  Last year's LGBTI Caucus attracted 8 people.  This year's attracted more than 100. 

You, our progressive friends, would have attended without the bells and whistles and we love you for it.  But many others in the room came who wouldn't have otherwise; they said so.  And we got a chance to talk to them about our issues.  In a Caucus that began at 6:00 pm, "Cher" only came on at 6:52 pm.  It was hardly as if serious business weren't being done. 

But before the event started, Diane Legriede, the executive director of the State Democratic Committee, pointed to "Cher" and said the following:

"We cannot have THAT walking in the hallway."

"You cannot have THAT inside your Caucus."

"The State Committee will not have someone like THAT attending dinner -- THAT cannot come inside the ballroom."

"What if the press sees THAT -- what if they report on THAT in tomorrow's papers?"

Diane delivered these statements as a diatribe in the hallway, ironically, drawing attention to an intolerance that was far more embarrassing than anything around her.  She was also completely unself-conscious about referring to a transgender person repeatedly as THAT -- as not even a person --  while standing right next to Barbra Casbar, a member of the transgender community who is a leader in the three organizations sponsoring the Caucus.

Steven Goldstein, Garden State Equality chair :: NJ Democratic State Committee repeats insensitivity to the LGBTI community
I answered:  "Diane, it's our caucus and transgender people are part of our community."  Joan Hervey of Garden State Equality added, "Diane, as a member of the LGBTI community, I am very offended."

Diane's response?  "It's not your event, it's our event."  What a telling statement.

She added, "If THAT's going to be inside the room, we're going to boycott your Caucus." 

Senator Loretta Weinberg and her staffer Debbie Francica were outraged on behalf of the LGBTI community.  They went to Diane and to Chair Joe Cryan and told it like it was:  "We can't believe your reaction.  You're acting like Republicans.  This is supposed to be a Democratic convention where we embrace diversity, not a Republican convention where we're afraid of it.  Transgender people are part of this community and they're entitled to be in that room and they include people like Cher."

Friends, we all know Loretta as one of the state's greatest progressive champions.  But as those of us who know her and her staff personally can attest -- and as this event proved -- they're also some of the most personally enlightened people you could ever meet in your lifetime. 

Also attending our Caucus were Congressman Frank Pallone, Union County Democratic Chair Charlotte DiFillippo and Senator Bob Menendez's daughter Alicia.  They all loved the event.  For those of you who don't know Alicia, she is one of the nicest, most politically savvy and most progressive young leaders in the Democratic Party today.  She, too, was in disbelief at the State Democratic Committee's reaction.  "Your community was the first to endorse my dad and I know everything you've done since.  I can't believe this."

Best of all, the entire Progressive Caucus not only joined us at the LGBTI Caucus, but also expressed passionate solidarity with us on our issues and against the State Committee's behavior.  Right on site, the executive board of New Jersey for Democracy voted to protest the State Committee's behavior.

Members of the press, as well as senior members of the Corzine Administration, thought the Cher idea was a blast.  We certainly don't blame Diane Legriede's meltdown on Governor Corzine, whose campaigns, Senate staff and gubernatorial Administration have all been more diverse than any we've ever seen in New Jersey.  Governor Corzine has appointed an unprecedented number of women, people of color and LGBTI New Jerseyans at the most senior levels of government.  He succeeded dramatically in lifting the glass ceiling.  God bless him.

But the State Committee continues to be an uptight, insensitive and LGBTI-uncomfortable mess that does not reflect the Democratic electorate in New Jersey, very likely the country's most progressive.  At the two previous year's conventions, party officials repeatedly singled out every constituency in their speeches except for the LGBTI community.  And they wonder why the LGBTI community wasn't attending the annual Democratic convention in higher numbers -- duh -- in contrast to Garden State Equality's grassroots town meetings that have drawn 10,000 people, straight and LGBTI alike, since 2003.

(Incidentally, the Democratic State Chair in recent years with the best record on diversity has been Tom Giblin.  He took several dramatic and courageous steps, a guy who walks the walk rather than just talks the talk.)

Diane Legriede's young operatives said her hallway diatribe reflected Chairman Joe Cryan's sentiments as well.  That's surprising -- we've found Joe to be a progressive, inclusive guy. 

We're troubled by the "boycott" of our Caucus when the state committee has no problem with our community's money and volunteers.  In the past two years, Garden State Equality has raised nearly $400,000, including more than well over $100,000 for political candidates.  Like our state's progressive organizations, we at GSE have triaged droves of volunteers to Democratic candidates.  We conceived and implemented a huge GOTV operation in 2005 and are about to unveil one for this fall's campaign.

The message Diane Legriede's diatribe sent was this:  We will accept you in the LGBTI community so long as you look and act a certain way.

Well, she and her state committee had better embrace the LGBTI community's diversity right now.  Our community is a rich and proud mosaic.  We range from those identify with genders different from their birth genders... to those who like to cross-dress... to those like me who wear suits, ties and even yarmulkes.  No one has the right to tell us who in our community is acceptable and who is not.  We are all acceptable and we all deserve respect.

If a state party leader in a comparably progressive state like California, New York or Massachusetts delived a transphobic, anti-LGBTI diatribe like that which Diane Legriede did in the hallway of this convention, that official might well be fired.

Rumor has it that Joe Cryan is going to call me to apologize.  I'll tell you what I'll tell him:  Words don't matter; action does.  The State Democratic Committee has got to take some very quick moves to diversify the party's leadership and number of elected officials.  It goes way beyond the party's lack of LGBTI diversity -- New Jersey's Democratic-dominated legislature ranks 44th nationally in the number of women officeholders.  Tragically, there's not a single openly LGBTI member of the state legislature or even on the State Democratic Committee.  At the 2004 Democratic National Convention, New Jersey had merely one openly LGBTI delegate whereas comparably progressive states each had many.

More than a seat at the table, we want action. 

It's time for the state Democratic Party to get the transgender equality bill passed this year -- 70 percent of New Jersey favors the bill whereas only 19 percent oppose it.  The Democrats have not even posted the bill in committee, stalling for nearly two years. 

It's time for the state Democratic Party to endorse marriage equality outright.  The state Democratic Parties of California, New York, Massachusetts, Washington State, Iowa, New Mexico and Texas have done so.  But it's New Jersey that has the strongest poll numbers for marriage equality in America, where two-thirds of all state Democrats favor marriage equality.

Quite simply, it's time for the State Democratic Committee to leave the Jurassic Era.

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
that's terrible (0.00 / 0)
It's time for marriage equality and full protection under the law.


I have to think of a witty signature about Frank LoBiondo

there EVER there were a more compelling reason.... (0.00 / 0)
...to pass into Law a bill protecting transgendered NewJerseyans, it's THIS!

I am ashamed that one of my trans sisters would be treaded so shabbily at the hands of and democratic operative at the convention. 

It HURTS to read this kind of stuff.

activist for hire.


And you want to know why some of us are demanding fealty to values? (0.00 / 0)
You want to know why some of us refuse to continue to support Democrats who will sell our values down the river for political expediency?  This is why.

Why should gay Democrats support a party where this kind of bigotry is in full view?  As I posted elsewhere, at least we citizens KNOW the Republicans are going to beat us silly.  These people will bring their constituents flowers and candy and tell them they love them -- and THEN beat them silly.


the Republican party (0.00 / 0)
As wrong as they usually are on issues of equality, the Republican party never had a monopoly on hate, and they still don't.

Wow (0.00 / 0)
I'm absolutely stunned. No words.

[ Parent ]
Intolerance or pragmatism? (0.00 / 0)
I like a good flaming drag queen act as much as the next reasonably liberal Jersey guy or gal--when watching The Bird Cage or going to a cabaret. And maybe Ms. Legriede overreacted. Maybe the New Jersey press really did think it was just a blast and wouldn't have devoted a lot ink or comment to it.

But we're in a close election, dammit -- even closer than it needs to be because once again, Corzine put blinkered politics ahead of common sense in making Menendez his successor.

Do we really need a repeat of 2004? There are those who think the impetuous, dare I say exhibitionist behavior of those who just couldn't resist thumbing their noses at America with their calculatingly high-profile "marriage ceremonies" cost John Kerry the election. And what has that gotten us? More people dead in Iraq, the further erosion of civil liberties and a demogogic President who trots out Karl Rove's cynical "Marriage Amendment" proposal during every election.

This is not about sexual identity or orientation either. It's about people who are so smug about their self-perceived "enlightment" that they just don't get it. In that I include the Whoopie Goldbergs of the world who don't understand that when you're entertaining at an official party function, you tone down your Vegas-style act, clean up your language and refrain from those "Bush-league" puns on female genitilia.

Things will never get better until Democrats take back the Congress and Presidency. And while we're happy to have the suppport of the LGBTI community, that doesn't give them the right to turn off more voters than they bring us.

In short, grow up and get a clue about the principle of delayed gratification. Election are serious business.


EWO, you're right - elections are serious business (4.00 / 2)
which is why the LGBTI community is pouring big sums of money and many volunteers into Democratic campaigns this year.  And I'm sorry you think the LGBTI community turns off more voters than they bring you - I can't speak for other states, but in New Jersey, I respectfully submit to you that you're wrong.  The LGBTI community is going to make a big difference in the extremely close Bob Menendez and Linda Stender races; and conversely in socially progressive New Jersey, we won't turn a voter off.  As far as non-progressives go, I think if "Cher" showed up at their doorstep giving them a property tax rebate, they'd give "her" a big wet kiss on the lips.  That's the issue people of every party and ideology care most about in New Jersey, as poll after poll demonstrates.  In fact, the polls show there's nary a soul in the entire state of New Jersey who votes on social issues - but when they do, they're as far to the left as voters in any other state in America.  According to a 2005 Zogby Poll, New Jersey favors a transgender equality statute 70 to 19 percent; full marriage equality for same-sex couples 56 to 39 percent; and opposes a state constitutional ban on marriage equality 67 to 28 percent.  All that said, I appreciate your different views and I thank you for your thoughtful response to my posting.  With every warm wish, Steven Goldstein

[ Parent ]
Thank you too, Mr. Goldstein (0.00 / 0)
for your measured and conciliatory response to my post. Perhaps you're right that Jersey voters are immune from exploitation on social issues, perhaps the New Jersey press is not likely to stir the pot about about the entertainment at a state party convention, and perhaps Fox News and other such "news" outlets wouldn't pick up on it. Nevertheless, perhaps you also can see why the Executive Director of the State Democratic Party might be concerned and why it doesn't necessarily make her "intolerant." As for her use of "that," I assume she was referring to the costume/get-up. Presumably, the Cher impersonator doesn't always look like "that." 

[ Parent ]
And if Redd Foxx were the featured performer (0.00 / 0)
at a Black Caucus session, would you still feel that that "unnecessary" voting block should tone it done or risk losing the election for the white folk??

Imagine how I as a gay man feel about your comments as to the appropriateness of a Cher impersonator. Perhaps we should get a tasteful, straight performer ... y'know, Tom Jones, or Elvis. Someone with real class.

LBGTI voters didn't defeat John Kerry, EWO. GWB did. Maybe.

Find me one g-damn voter who didn't vote for Kerry because of gay marriage. Starting .... now!

We await your response.

Clueless fool.

-d


[ Parent ]
"Imagine how I - I - I as a gay man feel about your comments." (0.00 / 0)
I'm talking about the pragmatic necessity of taking back the U.S. Congress and Presidency -- not for white people, not for gay people, but for all of America -- and you're making it all about you.

And yes, if I were the chair of the State Democratic Committee, and I had any concern that an obscenity-laced Redd Foxx performance at an official State Democratic Convention would be picked up by the media -- regardless of what caucus was sponsoring it -- I would ask that the caucus program directors keep their eyes on the prize and make sure they toned down the act.

Just look at the states that Bush won. A lot of them had gay marriage questions on the ballot, which also won. That wasn't a coincidence.

Don't you call me clueless, copycat. I already told you to grow up and get a clue about the principle of delayed gratification.


[ Parent ]
A little less arrogance and patronization, please... (4.00 / 2)
I don't agree that gay and lesbian people have a responsibility to suck up injustice in order to help achieve a vision of the "greater good" which comes at our expense.  I'm not talking about the incident at hand so much as your determination that marriage activists are to blame for John Kerry's loss.  You've got some nerve laying Iraq at our feet.  Get off your high horse.

And while we're happy to have the support of the LGBTI community, that doesn't give them the right to turn off more voters than they bring us.

Who appointed you to speak for the party?  LGBTI Democrats are as much a part of it as you are.  That's the whole point, and that's why this incident is infuriating.


[ Parent ]
In Other Words: "Be Realistic" (0.00 / 0)
(Sorry I'm late to this diary, somehow I missed it yesterday..)

I understand what you're saying "in between the lines". Republicans play on bigotry, racism, prejudice and all that "good" stuff.  Unfortunately for Republicans in NJ most of us Garden Staters are not bigoted.  This isn't a national election coming up in November. 

The NJ electorate/population is NOT Wyoming!

Is there bigotry here?  Yes, of course; but we've lost most of those folk to the Republican party here anyway (where ese can they go, eh?) .  Spend a few hours listening to WABC AM hate radio and you'll hear all manner of hatred coming from the callers and approved of overtly or tacitly by the "hosts".

The polls show that most New Jerseyans are a tolerant/accepting lot that believe in a live and let live philosophy.

Too bad Ms Legriede doesn't seem to share those values.

Insulting this community is not only morally wrong, it's bad politics!


[ Parent ]
small point on state ranking for women (4.00 / 1)
Just a small correction - NJ isn't 44th for the number of women in the legislature.  I don't want to take away from your main point - I find Diane Legreide's response inexplicable.  But I have a pet peeve about the way the rankings are done.  Last year NJ was 41st for women in the state legislature, and after Loretta Weinberg's move to the Senate, with a woman replacing her in the assembly, we leaped up to 31st according to CAWP.  I prefer to use IWPR's number, since they take into account Congress, Senate, governor and other statewide offices in states that have them (using a weighting system for the percentages).  As of their last report in 2004, NJ is 48th and in the 2006 report due this fall, Loretta's move to the Senate is not going to budge that number very much, only a win by Carol Gay, Linda Stender or Viola Thomas-Hughes will even start to put a dent in our ranking as 48th.  I'm glad to hear you will be and are helping Stender and know you will be helping Carol and hopefully Viola too. 

I like your line about the "state committee had better embrace the LGBTI community's diversity right now."  I would add, the state committee needs to embrace diversity in general right now.  They made an announcement about starting meetings around the state at the beginning of next year about recruiting and mentoring women in partnership with CAWP, so I hope that those meetings will yield results. And I hope that with Alicia Menendez starting up Women for Menendez, she will reach out to the three women running for Congress and really get these campaigns coordinated on the ground.


GREAT LETTER, STEVEN! (0.00 / 0)
Let's burn the (rhymes with witch).

Amazing. Simply amazing.

Any person subscribing to this list that doesn't send Ms. L. a full ration of you know what, shouldn't be here.

More Later!

-d


Cher Tribute (0.00 / 0)
well, actually, this all really depends if the Cher impersonator was singing old Cher crap like "Gypsies, Tramps & Theives" or new stuff like "Do you believe in life after Love," and beyond. After all we need to keep hip with the times and have to demonstrate our party has bold and new ideas.  Now a Hillary impersonator would be in bad taste.

this is line in the sand time (0.00 / 0)
While I would not propose that the Democratic Congressional and Senatorial candidates, running for office this year be punished in any way for the actions (or failure to act - see Steven's specific actions) of our elected officials, party leaders, and party operatives who allowed the despicable incident described by Steven to take place without any accountability thus far, if we can look ahead to 2007 for a moment, we will see a unique opportunity unfolding in NJ politics.

Without a single statewide office up for election in 2007, State Senator will be the highest office on the ballot, ensuring extremely low turnout, especially during the primary election season.  As a result, every Democratic State Senator and State Assemblyperson running for re-election in 2007 must be required to take a public position on these and other issues of concern to the progressive community and LGBTI community or face a primary challenge from a real progressive alternative.

Obviously, we know where real progressives like Loretta Weinberg, Reed Gusciora, and Linda Stender (although we hope that her time in the State Assembly ends relatively soon after she defeats Mike Ferguson in November) stand, but far too many others talk a good game when it means collecting a check or an endorsement from Garden State Equality, but when push comes to shove, they need to stand up alongside progressive Democrats who will no longer tolerate intolerance within our party, big tent or not.

To be fair to Diane, when I joined the board of Garden State Equality it was specifically to support the organization's marriage equality effort as part feelings of obligation that I felt towards the gay and lesbian community related to my own wedding in July of 2005.  However, when I was introduced to the transgender community, my first reaction was very negative and I even went so far as to cite them as the primary obstacle preventing the LGBTI community from winning marriage equality.  That was until I met people like Babs Casbar, got to know them, understood the issues that they were dealing with, and realized that they were just as much a part of the LGBTI community as gays and lesbians and that their issues are just as important as marriage equality.

That said, because of the degree to which they all influence policymaking and are the names and the faces of the Democratic Party, elected officials, party leaders, and party operatives cannot afford to have the same learning curve as me or any other regular citizen.  They have to educate themselves very quickly or at the very least "fake it until they make it" so that embarrassing incidents like what happened on Friday do not happen ever again.

When the recent battles for equality were fought and won in places like Ocean County, Atlantic County, and Cape May County, it was easy to discount the behavior of the elected officials in question as being that of typical right-wing Republicans, who live in the reddest parts of the state and don't know any better.  But this incident proves that for the progressive and LGBTI communities to win battles in the future, we have to be willing to take on both Democrats and Republicans in both the bluest and reddest parts of the state and everywhere in between.

I understand that there are battles in November that have to be fought and won first, but I hope that progressives don't choose to wait until the day after Election Day to begin to demand accountability from their State Senators and State Assemblypersons.

And while many of our progressive leaders might be very proud about the relationships that they have developed with Joe Cryan and other elected officials and party leaders and the degree to which these relationships have enhanced their individual profiles in NJ politics, I would hope that they understand that it is times like these where these relationships are most important and must be leveraged for the good of the community-at-large.

If our leaders determine that the good of the community-at-large is not worth leveraging their relationships with people like Joe Cryan and possibly putting them at risk, then they should probably not be holding leadership positions anymore and this should be considered as a line in the sand moment for them as well.


primaries are key (0.00 / 0)
For those of us who advocate voting for the Democrat over the Republicans despite disagreements, the avenue for change is the party primary system, and of couse public criticism.


I have to think of a witty signature about Frank LoBiondo

[ Parent ]
Keeping hoping (0.00 / 0)
Our new acting county chair just told us that he wants to avoid competitive primaries wherever he can. I was talking about why the unaffiliated percentage is so high in NJ, how to get more people to affiliate, and mentioning that voters get that their vote doesn't matter which is why the '04 primary turnout in Mdlsx and Mercer was 6% and 7% of registered voters.

Even the primary for governor (at least when Corzine brought his money to the table) was over before it got to the voters, and as a consequence so was the primary for Corzine's Senate seat.  I've heard the figure that 40% of either the assembly or legislature (I don't remember which) is there by appointment.  Coming from CA this kind of system is foreign.  Maybe I didn't pay close enough attention in CA, but in my old district Jane Harman was denied the line on the in-district vote and had to go to the state convention in Sacramento to get her endorsement over the issue of the war (and the progressives challenged her even there on the floor, altho they lost.  And there was a platform voted on, by they way, which this year was pretty darn progressive) . What did Steve say?  Jurassic?

Somebody said to me the other day how remarkable it is that the Dem party is afraid of its base.  I think there's some truth to that.


[ Parent ]
yeah, I agree (0.00 / 0)
Viola had a primary, basically due to a mistake, since as I heard it the other guy thought no one was signing up. 

I think the party at all scales makes a mistake avoiding contested primaries.  To be sure, there are nasty primaries that hurt -- the Penns Grove primary is in court, which can't be a good sign for party unity --  and kos has been bitterly complaining that the two Dem gov. candidates in CA just attacked each other the whole time.  The politicians complain that we have no vote in the Presidential primaries, yet the politicians try to make sure that we don't have a vote in any primary. 

Over in PA, it is hard to tell what is going on, but it sure seems like the annointed Casey is turning out to be a weak candidate.  If he blows that race and leaves us with Santorum, Schumer (who selected him) should be recalled. 



I have to think of a witty signature about Frank LoBiondo


[ Parent ]
Does NJ 101.5 know about this (3.00 / 1)
I can see the obnoxious radio personalities at NJ 101.5 having a field day with this issue.

ADVERTISEMENT
Featured Stories

Blue Jersey Radio

The Voice of NJ Politics
» Next show: Tues. @ 8:00p
» Hosts: Jeff Gardner & Jay Lassiter
» Call in: (646) 652-2773
» iTunes Subscribe | Archives



Connect with
Blue Jersey

Hate Ads? Make them disappear.
Subscribe:

Blue Jersey Essentials

 EDITORIAL DIRECTOR
 Rosi Efthim

 STAFF WRITERS
 Adam L a/k/a/ clammyc
 Bill Orr
 bytheshore73
 Hopeful
 Jay Lassiter
 Jeff Gardner
 Scott Weingart
 Senator Loretta Weinberg
 Vincent Solomeno
 Rosi Efthim

» About | FAQ | In the News
» 
» Tips:
» Front Page RSS Feed
» User Diaries RSS Feed
» Blue Jersey on Twitter » Blue Jersey on Facebook » Blue Jersey T-shirts
ADVERTISEMENT

Blog Roll

» Alicia Menendez
» Alive and Kickin
» Barista of Bloomfield Ave
» Blog the Fifth
» Capitol Quickies
» The Center of NJ Life
» Channel Surfing
» Daily Newarker
» The Englewood Report
» Frank Lobiondo Record
» Fred Snowflack
» Freedom to Tinker
» Fresh Jersey (Mike Kelly)
» Garden State Grapevine
» Gloucester City News
» Green Jersey
» Herb Jackson
» Hoboken Journal
» Hoboken Now
» The Inside Clamdigger
» Jersey Blogs
» Jersey Jazz Man
» Lassiter Space
» Latinos NJ
» Middletown Mike
» More Monmouth Musings
» NJ Domestic Partnership
» NJ Politics Unusual
» NJ Voices: Policy Watch
» On Our Radar
» The Opinion Mill
» Other Spaces
» Plainfield Plaintalker
» PolitickerNJ
» Retire Garrett
» Ruins of Trenton
» Senator Ray Lesniak
» Stovetop Diplomacy
» Sustainable Cherry Hill
» The Subversive Garden
» Teaneck Progress
» Trenton Kat
» We Don't Need Permission
» Xpatriated Texan

Cartoons

» M.e. Cohen
» Jimmy Margulies
» Drew Sheneman
» Rob Tornoe
Search




Advanced Search










Ads do not constitute
an endorsement
from Blue Jersey.



Blue Jersey Gear

Visit the Blue Jersey store. T-shirts, bumper stickers & more!


Shirts available in dozens of styles and colors.






Visit the Blue Jersey Store

Contact Us
» Editor: 
» Press releases: 
» Advertising inquiries: 
» Tips:
About Us
» About Blue Jersey
» Blue Jersey in the News
» FAQ/Usage
» 
» RSS Feed

Misc Stuff
» Blue Jersey Radio
» Blue Jersey on Twitter
» Facebook Group
» MySpace Page
» NJ Politics 101 Wiki
» Blue Jersey Podcast
» Screaming Carrot Award
» Contribute to Blue Jersey
6409 satisfied users, visits and 0 subpoenas served since Sept 28, 2005
© Blue Jersey, powered by the mighty SoapBlox.